You post a remote role on Monday and wake up to a flood of applicants. Two of them look great. By the time you call on Wednesday, both have taken other offers. Plenty of advice on how to hire remote employees treats this as a distance problem: post nationwide, pick from the bigger pile.
A bigger pile exposes the weak parts of your hiring process faster. Across all industries in our 2025 Recruiting Metrics Report, employers got 180 applicants per hire and invited only 3% to interview. Going remote widens the top of that funnel and leaves the bottom as it was.
What changes? You lose the handshake and the feel of someone in the lobby. Your hiring process has to make up for that with a clear role, a fast reply, a real look at the work, and a first week that connects people.
We know what that looks like firsthand. CareerPlug is a remote company, and our founder, Clint Smith, writes in How to Hire: “Ultimately, we decided that we valued access to nationwide talent and increased flexibility over all of us being together at an office in Austin.”
We’re in good company, too. In October 2026, the Bureau of Labor Statistics found that 23.3% of office and administrative support workers and 23.6% of sales workers did at least some of their work from home.
Here’s the system for hiring remote employees:
- Step 1: Define the remote role and how you’ll work
- Step 2: Write a job post that tells the truth about remote work
- Step 3: Hiring remote workers: recruit beyond the job boards
- Step 4: Respond within a day
- Step 5: Screen with questions before anyone gets a video call
- Step 6: Run your remote interview process over video, with a human making the call
- Step 7: See the work, then check references
- Step 8: Make the offer face to face, on video
- Step 9: How to onboard remote employees so they meet the team in week one
1. Define the remote role and how you’ll work
Write down what success looks like in results, because you won’t see the person at a desk. Our Remote First Vision says it this way: “We track your results, not your time.” Spell out the results the role owns and how you’ll measure them. Could a stranger read your notes and tell, after a month, whether the hire is going well?
Then decide who you’re looking for. Clint writes, “When I think about the hiring process, only three things matter when evaluating a candidate”: Can they do it? (Ability) Will they do it? (Motivation) Will others do it with them? (Culture fit). For a remote role, culture fit includes how someone communicates in writing and on video. Our guide to how to hire for culture fit goes deeper, and the hiring process steps help you put all of it on paper.
Going remote changed our culture, and Clint says so plainly: “We lost our office culture, but we replaced it with something stronger: a deep commitment to a culture of personal growth and development.”
2. Write a job post that tells the truth about remote work
Spell out the hours, the time zones you need covered, the tools, and how the team communicates. Applicants can’t walk your office, so the posting is their first look at how you work. Our Remote First Vision puts it simply: “Over-communication is the name of the game.” Say that in the post, then show what you mean: how often the team checks in and where the conversation happens.
Lead with what’s in it for them, like the work itself and how you support people who work on their own. Include your pay range. Here’s the shape of a good opening:
Remote scheduling coordinator. Hours: 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. Central, Monday to Friday. You’ll work in our scheduling software, a shared inbox, a team message board, and video calls. You’ll check in with your manager each morning on video, and we cover training in your first week.
If you want a fuller format to start from, try our guide to writing effective job descriptions. Job posting software then sends one posting to many boards. Could a candidate tell from yours what a normal Tuesday looks like?
3. Hiring remote workers: recruit beyond the job boards
Remote tempts you to post everywhere, so start with the channels that turn applicants into hires. In our 2026 Franchise Hiring Report, job boards supplied 65% of applicants but just 47% of hires at service franchises. Compared with job board applicants, referred applicants were hired 5.9x as often, and careers page applicants 1.9x as often. (Those figures come from service franchises. They don’t break out remote roles, so read them as a guide.)
Clint’s line fits: “You need to recruit them. And you need to recruit like you sell.” On referrals, he writes, “Your best customers often come from referrals; the same is true for your best employees.” In Clint’s Notes, he adds, “Loyal customers refer new customers. Engaged employees refer good candidates.”
Put your careers page first, and give your team a reason to refer with an employee referral program.
4. Respond within a day
Reply to good applicants within a day, because a remote candidate is one browser tab away from the next offer. In the same report, service franchise applicants who heard back within 24 hours were scheduled for interviews 31% of the time. When the wait ran to four weeks, that fell to 11.5%, a 2.7x gap.
Clint’s version: “Great leads are like French fries: they are at their best when they are fresh and hot!” He adds, “Some clients say that the shelf life of a good applicant in their field is 48 hours.” (Yes, that includes the person who applied at 11 p.m. from another time zone.)
We start with a face. In How to Hire, Clint describes the short video every applicant to CareerPlug gets from Natalie, our People leader. She introduces herself and explains what to expect from our hiring process. Tools for text recruiting and candidate communication keep replies quick, and our time to hire guide can help you find the slow spots.
5. Screen with questions before anyone gets a video call
Ask a few prescreen questions the moment someone applies, because most of your pile never needs a video call. Across all industries in our 2025 report, only 3% of applicants got an interview. Clint says prescreen questions “may be the biggest time saver in the entire hiring process.”
Ask about the remote basics: working hours and home setup, plus experience working on their own. Then do a short phone screen with the people who pass. With applicant screening software, the questions go out as soon as someone applies, so a good applicant hears from you right away.
6. Run your remote interview process over video, with a human making the call
Ask structured questions about ability and motivation, plus culture fit, and keep a person in charge of the decision. Use the same questions for every candidate and test the video tool before the call, then tell people what happens next.
Let candidates book their own interview time so time zones don’t slow you down. Posting jobs and screening for basic requirements, plus scheduling? Clint says in Clint’s Notes, “All of that can and should be automated.” Then comes the catch: “But evaluating whether someone should be hired? That isn’t something you want to hand off to an algorithm.” He adds, “Great hires don’t come solely from algorithmic pattern matching. They come from a real human having a conversation with another real human.”
Across all industries, 27% of interviews became hires, which makes each one worth preparing for. Our guide to conducting job interviews covers the rest.
7. See the work, then check references
You can’t watch a remote hire work, so give your finalists a job simulation. Ours is simple: “For our support representatives, we do a support call simulation and also ask them to respond to a support email.” Clint puts the reason in one line: “There is no substitute for seeing how candidates actually work.”
Pick a task from the real job and keep it short, then score every finalist the same way. Candidate evaluation tools help you compare notes. Before you offer, run employer background checks where your process calls for them, and use our reference check questions when you call references.
Background check rules vary by state, so check the official sources. What’s the one task that would show you a candidate can do this job on their own?
8. Make the offer face to face, on video
Review the offer together on a video call, so it feels like a conversation. Here’s how we do it, in Clint’s words: “For remote hires, we do a video call and send the candidate an email with the offer package at the start of the call so that we can review it together, ‘face-to-face.’” Answer their questions on the call, and ask when they’ll get back to you.
Hiring someone in another state or country brings tax, payroll, registration, and employment rules that vary. Before you extend the offer, check the federal U.S. Department of Labor and IRS sites, along with your own state’s labor and tax agencies.
P.S. Building teams across many franchise locations, in the office or remote? The Franchise People Playbook shows franchisors how to make hiring a competitive advantage in every location.
9. How to onboard remote employees so they meet the team in week one
Plan week one so the new hire meets the team on video before they do much else. Clint writes, “Your new hire’s first week sets the tone and trajectory for their time with you.” At CareerPlug, new hires have one-on-one video calls with their team and get an introduction on our internal message board, plus a “getting to know you” email with their answers to a few fun questions.
Remote meetings need a rule, and ours comes from the Remote First Vision: “If one person is remote at a meeting, we all are.” Clint is honest about the cost, too: “collaboration and connection in general have been challenging.” “The #1 recruiting strategy is retention,” he writes, and for a fuller week-one plan, see onboarding and team management. Who will your new hire talk to first, and when?
How to hire remote employees: start with the results the role owns
Before you post your next remote role, write down the results it owns and how you’ll check them, then share that page with the first person you interview. See how small businesses post, screen, and schedule in one place.
This guide is the short version. The full playbook for hiring and keeping great people is Clint’s book, How to Hire.