“Lawyers told us to stay out of it.” — Clint Smith, CareerPlug CEO, on what franchisors told him at IFA 2026
You can avoid joint employer risk and still help your franchisees hire great people. The legal line sits at control over individual employment decisions: who gets hired, fired, paid, scheduled, or disciplined. Sharing data, benchmarks, templates, and playbooks across your system stays well on the safe side. (Your lawyers’ caution makes sense. Going quiet because of it is where the real cost shows up.)
Our 2026 Franchise Hiring Report draws on data from 46,000+ franchise locations, 7.5 million applicants, and approximately 90,000 hires. That’s the kind of network-level insight franchisors can use to coach franchisees without taking over their employment decisions. And the pressure is real: franchise hiring fell about 15% when comparing January–May 2026 with the same period in 2025. Franchisees need support now, and staying silent costs more.
Here’s what follows: where the legal line sits and which decisions stay with franchisees, then five steps for coaching, equipping, documenting, and training. What would change if every franchisee hired like your best one? Keep reading for the full playbook.
Table of contents
- What joint employer liability means
- Direct vs. indirect risk
- Decisions to stay out of
- Step 1: Coach with shared data
- Step 2: Equip each franchisee
- Step 3: Agreements and acknowledgments
- Step 4: Independence and documentation
- Step 5: Field staff training
- The American Franchise Act
- Frequently asked questions
Joint employer liability starts where a franchisor controls individual employment decisions
Joint employer liability means two businesses can both be treated as the employer of the same worker. In a franchise, it comes down to whether the franchisor’s involvement protects the brand or reaches into how people are actually employed. Clint puts the bright line this way:
“The legal line is ‘substantial direct and immediate control’ over individual employment decisions.” — Clint Smith
As of February 27, 2026, the National Labor Relations Board uses the 2020 standard. A franchisor counts as a joint employer only when it both holds and actually uses substantial, direct, and immediate control over essential terms of employment, such as wages, hours, hiring, termination, and discipline. Our guide to providing employment resources without becoming a joint employer covers what’s safe to offer.
Direct risk comes from what you do, and indirect risk comes from what you reserve
A franchise system can cross the line in two ways.
Direct control risk
Direct control means a franchisor dictates hiring, firing, pay, or scheduling for a specific person. Picture a corporate office approving one cashier’s raise, or a field consultant telling an owner to cut one person’s hours.
Indirect control risk
Indirect control comes from rules and systems that could be read as reserved control. Agreement language that gives the franchisor a say in individual employment matters is the classic case, even if the franchisor never uses it. Under the current standard, control that stays indirect or reserved, or only appears once in a while, doesn’t create joint employer status by itself. Cleaner documents still take the argument off the table.
Five employment decisions stay with the franchisee: hiring, firing, wages, scheduling, and discipline
A franchisor should stay out of five decisions about individual people: hiring, firing, wages, scheduling, and discipline. Each one belongs to the franchisee alone, from who gets an offer to how someone is corrected. Staying out of them doesn’t mean going silent:
“Sharing best practices across your system is nowhere near that line.” — Clint Smith
Here’s a simple test. A franchisor can publish a 24-hour response benchmark for the whole system. It shouldn’t tell one franchisee to hire, or turn down, a particular applicant. See the first five things to know about hiring compliance. Which of those five does your field team come closest to touching?
Step 1: Coach the whole network with shared data to avoid joint employer risk
To avoid joint employer risk, share best practices system-wide and leave each location’s decisions to its franchisee.Our 2026 Franchise Hiring Report shows what’s worth sharing:
| Benchmark | What it shows | A practice you can coach |
|---|---|---|
| Hires from channels other than job boards | More than 50% of franchise hires, though job boards remain the largest single source | A mix of channels |
| Referral candidates | 5.9x as likely to be hired as the job-board baseline | A shared referral program template |
| Careers-page candidates | 1.9x as likely to be hired | A branded careers page for each franchisee |
| Contact within 24 hours | 2.7x the interview-schedule rate of contact after four or more weeks | The 24-hour speed rule |
As Clint writes, “The Franchise People Playbook lays out the building blocks in a format you can use yourself and share with your franchisees.” You share the number, and the franchisee decides what to do with it. Our guide to setting franchisees up for hiring success shows what’s worth sharing, and our 2025 Recruiting Metrics Report adds by-industry benchmarks.
Step 2: Equip each franchisee on their own account
Give every franchisee their own hiring account, with its own tracking system and careers page, so each decision stays with the person who owns it. (It’s fair to ask whether handing franchisees software counts as control. Generally it doesn’t, because the software supports their decisions and never makes them.)
CareerPlug is built this way. Franchisors get visibility and coaching tools through PartnerHub, and every franchisee runs hiring on their own account, separate by design. More than 400 franchise brands run hiring on CareerPlug. See how it works in our franchise hiring software and applicant tracking system for franchises, or read about franchisors and networks.
A Molly Maid franchisee grew her team from 7 to 10 employees on her own account, making her own hires. The Goddard School saw a 70% increase in applicant volume and a 50% decrease in recruitment cost.
Step 3: Write agreements and acknowledgments that name the franchisee as sole employer
Your agreement and employee acknowledgments should say plainly that the franchisee alone employs its people.
In the franchise agreement, name the franchisee as the sole employer and state that it alone hires, fires, pays, schedules, and disciplines. Keep brand standards on the brand and the customer experience, and trim any reserved rights over individual employment decisions. In employee acknowledgments, have people confirm in writing that they work for the franchisee and nobody else. Put the franchisee’s name on offer letters and handbooks too.
Our guide to brand standards and employment brand shows how to keep one look without blurring who the employer is. Have franchise counsel read the wording first.
Step 4: Keep franchisees independent, and coach them to document it
Franchisees keep their HR independence by making their own decisions and writing down how they made them.That means setting role criteria before interviewing, asking every candidate the same core questions, noting why each person was hired or passed over, and keeping signed acknowledgments and personnel records in the franchisee’s own name. (Yes, it’s a little tedious. It’s also what makes the rest easy to defend.)
The franchisor’s job is to coach the process and hand over templates a franchisee can adopt or change. Our guide to structuring the recruiting process for franchises can help. Could your franchisees show, in writing, why they hired the last person they hired?
P.S. Coaching franchisees across multiple locations? Start with The Franchise People Playbook.
Step 5: Train field staff to advise on outcomes and stay out of individual decisions
Field staff should advise on brand standards and business results, and stay out of individual employment decisions.Safe phrases sound like “Here’s what’s working across the system, and it’s your call,” or “Check with your own HR resource or counsel on that.” Phrases to retire sound like “Hire that applicant,” or “Take her off the schedule.” Have field staff route employment questions back to the franchisee.
The American Franchise Act would write the narrow standard into law
The American Franchise Act (H.R. 5267 / S. 3525) would turn today’s narrow standard into federal law under both the National Labor Relations Act and the Fair Labor Standards Act, which a future administration couldn’t undo. It cleared a House committee in July 2026 with roughly 142 bipartisan cosponsors and International Franchise Association backing. It hasn’t passed the House floor, and the Senate path is harder.
“The American Franchise Act cannot pass soon enough.” — Clint Smith
Until then, today’s standard governs. Our guide to the American Franchise Act framework tracks what could change.
Common questions about avoiding joint employer risk
What is joint employer liability in a franchise?
Joint employer liability means a franchisor and franchisee are both treated as employers of the franchisee’s staff. A franchisor only reaches that point by controlling terms like pay or discipline for specific people.
Can a franchisor provide hiring software without becoming a joint employer?
Generally yes. A franchisor can provide hiring software when each franchisee uses its own account and makes its own decisions, and the franchisor never uses the software to pick candidates or set schedules.
What employment decisions must a franchisor stay out of?
A franchisor must leave five calls about individual employees to the franchisee: hiring, firing, wages, scheduling, and discipline. Sharing benchmarks and training across the system stays on the safe side.
How should franchisees maintain independence in their HR decisions?
Franchisees maintain HR independence by making every decision about their own staff and keeping records that show it: a hiring account in their own name, written role criteria, recorded reasons for each choice, and signed acknowledgments.
How does the American Franchise Act change joint employer concerns for franchisors?
The American Franchise Act would write the narrow joint employer standard into federal law. At the time of writing, the Act has cleared a House committee (July 2026) but not the House floor, so today’s standard governs.
What should a franchisee do to strengthen HR documentation to reduce liability?
A franchisee should keep a consistent paper trail: written job descriptions, a standard set of interview questions, notes explaining each hiring choice, signed acknowledgments, and discipline records kept in the franchisee’s own name.
Avoid joint employer risk by coaching the network and equipping each franchisee
Pick one best practice this week, such as the 24-hour reply rule, and share it with every franchisee in writing, with the data and an invitation to adapt it. That’s coaching. As Clint says, “staying stuck is almost always more expensive than moving forward.”
Mad Science shows it at scale: a nationwide, franchisor-level partnership across multiple franchise groups, with postings syndicated to eight or more job boards. “CareerPlug has found me more applicants and applicants of higher quality,” says a Mad Science franchisee. For the full playbook, read Clint’s book, How to Hire.